Had allergic reactions several different times while trying to ensure it was the product. Cleaned off tip after each application, done several weeks apart. The allergic reaction described was as previous review. Product not used on inner rim of eye.
Thought I'd give these liners a try, but was very disappointed when the color portion of the first one IMMEDIATELY broke off at the base leaving it unusable. This is a design flaw so I'm anticipating the other two colors doing the same thing. Very disappointing!
CassyRock, West Virginia
I have weird eyes. They are both green and brown, but one is greener than the other so if i take pictures in certain lighting they look like two different colors. It doesn't help I have huge framed glasses and brunette blunt bangs. I'm in love with the green in my eyes but if I use other liners and kohls for my eye color, they result in an allergic reaction. <br />Someone told me to try PF and I found this and the liners at Walmart. I have to say I loved it. It glides on so smoothly, looks great behind my frames, and best of all, no reaction! I love my liner thick so this is my favorite so far. If only it wouldn't smudge so easily.
ArleneStatesville, North Carolina
I bought these last night. I org. had the Maybelline Kohl liner but then I saw this three pack and thought I would give it a try. I like them. They seemed to glide right on. I did not have a bad affect on my eyes with them. I have sensitive eyes and I did not have any problems. I'm thinking maybe with the one reviewer she was getting an eye infection, then she applied the make-up and it made the infection symptoms worse. Now the infection is on the pencil, and she reapplied it to her eye transferring it to the pencil the first time. I'm not a dr. but it just may have been bad timing on her part. I will continue to use and if I get any bad results I will repost, but so far the only complaint I have is I may need to reapply, it's not as strong on my face after five hours of wear. But makeup has a hard time staying on, I have oily skin.
My daughter works for shoppers drug mart and brought this product home. I had first tried the green and my eyes became slightly itchy and red so i washed the product off. just this past saturday (09/06/14) i wanted to give the product a try again, so i used the purple. within a couple of hours both of my eyes were burning, itchy, red and a film had formed over my pupils causing a blurr. my eyes felt like there was sand on the eye. at 2:50 am my eyes were completely puss crusted closed and seeping in the corners. i had to pry my eyelashes apart. i washed both of my eyes and put eye drops in. my eyes stung so badly. i woke at 9 am and again my eyes were pussed closed and i had to repeat the process..my eyes bothered me all day and i again woke this morning 09/08/14 with very sory red dry eyes and puffy eyelids..i will never use the product again as to the severity of the alergic reaction.