I bought this because I have eyeshadow I love and thought why not; plus its "waterproof" not! . Not only is it not water proof the stuff runs and smudges I look terrible wearing it. There is no Drama with the colors they are muted, the black is more like a dark gray, the blue is a dark navy the brown is barley there. I bought a cheap Wet and Wild blue liquid eyeliner just to see how I would like blue eyeliner. I loved it. So I thought I would buy "good" stuff; well I wasted my money. Im very very disappointed with this product.
The eyeliner itself is really nice, but the design of the container just doesn't make any sense. I tried 2 different liners from the package both broke the second time i used it. Waste of time and money!
I bought this because it claimed that it was waterproof. I love gel liner, because it is actually waterproof and lasts all day, but these sticks looked easier. They are more portable and don't require a brush to apply. Well, they are not only not waterproof, if I touch the liner at all, it wipes right off. The gel liners from PF, are soooo much better.
The pigment on these are pretty weak as well. I have fair skin, so there should not be any problem with eyeliner showing up. The black looks more like a dark grey. The blue looks washed out. The brown was almost translucent.
I am very very disappointed with this product.